Postal History · Ship Letter · Bermuda Station

H.M.S. Acorn

Bermuda · 6 April 1828

A letter from a young sailor to his sister, written four days before Acorn sailed from Bermuda for Halifax and was lost with all hands.

◆

Some items take a while to reveal their story, and this is one of them. At first glance it’s a rather tired entire from Bermuda: heavily crossed through, readdressed, with a faint red ship letter mark and writing running in just about every direction. It was written aboard HMS Acorn at Bermuda on Sunday 6 April 1828 by a young man named William Clarke, to his sister Mary.

Four days later Acorn sailed for Halifax. She never arrived, and nothing more was heard of her or anyone aboard.

William’s letter took a different route and did reach home. His father opened it, wrote his own news around the edges and sent it on to Mary at Cambridge. Some time later he wrote on the front: “My dear lost son William’s letters”.

The letter came to me from Gerald Ellott. Gerald, who died in December 2024 at the age of 98, was one of New Zealand’s great philatelists. He was an architect by profession, a past president of the Royal Philatelic Society of New Zealand, signed the Roll of Distinguished Philatelists in 1988 and was awarded the FIP Research Medal. I first met him when I was nine, around 1982 or 1983, and we corresponded and kept in touch right up until his death. Gerald was a master researcher and had already done a good deal of work on this letter. I’ve been able to take it quite a bit further, and I think he’d be happy with that.

The entire, opened out

Click a number to see what each marking and note is. The numbers follow the letter’s journey, from William’s pen to his father’s last note.

The Acorn entire opened out flat, showing the address panel, Ralph Clarke's notes on the flaps, the red wax seals and the postal markings
The entire opened out: outer side
I

“On Thursday for certain we sail for Halifax”

First page of William Clarke's letter, headed H.M. Sloop Acorn, Bermuda, Sunday April 6th 1828, with Ralph Clarke's note written upside down across the top
Page one, with Ralph’s note upside down across the top
Second page of William Clarke's letter
Page two
Third page of William Clarke's letter, signed Your affectionate Brother Wm Clarke
Page three, signed “Wm Clarke”

William’s letter is long, chatty and full of family. There is nothing in it to suggest he had any worries about what lay ahead. Quite the opposite.

He opens with the practical news. Acorn would sail for Halifax on Thursday “for certain”. One of the ship’s mates was being invalided home and had promised to carry the letter safely to England in a transport that had recently arrived with provisions. That one sentence turns out to be the key to the whole postal story, but more on that below.

He’s clearly excited about the move north, and just as clearly wondering what he’s in for: “I can scarcely believe that in a few days I shall be in a Country so different to this, where the very breath of one freezes.” The Bermuda thermometer, he tells her, had never dropped below 55 or 56 and usually sat between 65 and 75.

“I long to be on the move and look forward with pleasure to visit other Parts of the world.” He expected to be away about two years. Someone he calls Taff had promised him a letter of introduction to relations of “the doctor” at Halifax.

Then comes a passage I find hard to read past. Talking about sailing with Mary when he gets home, he writes:

“The Shoals are certainly dangerous but the wind is not if proper care is taken to carry a snug Sail & not carry on too much — You will be able to make out what I mean no doubt.”

I want to be careful here. Nobody knows what happened to Acorn, and I’m not suggesting this line tells us anything about it. It’s a young man showing his sister that he’s learning his trade. But knowing what came four days later, it does make you stop.

The rest is family. He wants to know how long Mary will stay at Penzance and what her plans are after visiting Chilbolton. He sends love to Aunt Cousens, remembrance to Uncle D, and “my Love and a Kiss to Missy”. There’s a lovely bit of gossip about Lady Curtis, who he’d seen in the paper “was again confined what a Breeder!!”, followed straight away by the assurance that “Lady C is such a nice woman that I quite love her.”

He admires John, almost certainly his brother, for saying nothing about a disappointment and simply reporting his appointment to the infantry: “He would do well in any thing from a Tinker to a King.” He is grateful to their father, who “is all kindness to me and I may say that I was fitted out in every thing proper for a Gent.”

Like a lot of sailors, he was collecting. He had pieces of a curious stone “blown from the rocks” that he was keeping safe in his chest until he came home, because sending them would cost more than they were worth. He apologises that Bermuda “is the worst Station for Shells that there is”.

He signs off “I have now spun you a long Yarn”. In a postscript he adds that he’d written to their father a few days earlier by the packet. That small detail comes back later.

II

Who was William Clarke?

The letter gives us William, Mary, a father, a brother called John and a string of relations and friends. It took some digging to turn that into a family.

The best fit, and I’m now fairly confident of it, is the William Clarke born at Clanville in Hampshire on 15 June 1812. He was the son of Ralph Clarke, Esq. and his wife Mary Christian, née Mount. His sister Mary Christian Clarke was baptised at Longparish in 1809, and his brother John was born at Clanville in 1810. Clanville turns up again in Ralph’s own notes on the letter, which was a nice moment.

The Clarke family

  • Ralph Clarke, widower, of Warkworth, marries Mary Christian Mount at Merton, Surrey, 16 August 1806
  • Mary Christian Clarke, baptised at Longparish, 2 March 1809
  • John Clarke, born at Clanville, 11 November 1810
  • William Clarke, born at Clanville, 15 June 1812
  • Mary marries William Nunn, Esq., at New Fishbourne, 6 October 1827

If I have the right William, he was fifteen years and nine months old when he wrote from Bermuda. That seemed young to me at first, but it wasn’t unusual for a boy from a gentleman’s family starting out in the Navy.

Six months earlier, on 6 October 1827, Mary had married William Nunn, Esquire, of Streatham, at New Fishbourne near Chichester. She was still a minor, and the register records her father’s consent. Among the witnesses are Ralph, John and William Clarke, and a Fanny Croft, who also appears in Ralph’s notes on the letter. So William was very likely at his sister’s wedding shortly before he sailed. The “Wm” whose health he asks after is most naturally Mary’s new husband.

What I haven’t yet established is William’s position aboard. Everything about him points to a young gentleman at the start of a naval career: his family, his education, his father fitting him out “proper for a Gent”. But I don’t want to call him a midshipman, or anything else, until I’ve seen the evidence. I had the Acorn muster (ADM 37/7331) searched at The National Archives, and William wasn’t found in it. That doesn’t mean he isn’t there, and there could be any number of reasons he wasn’t found. One is that the volume doesn’t run up to April 1828, so he may have joined after its last entries. That would fit with him being at Mary’s wedding in England in October 1827. I have copies of the pages and will go through them myself when I can. To add a little confusion, Acorn’s Master was a William Clarke Purver. He is not our William.

Lady Curtis is very probably Lady Mary Curtis, wife of the naval officer Sir Lucius Curtis, who had a large family. “William C.” may well be their son Roger William Curtis, then almost eleven. Others in the letter remain unidentified for now: Douglas, Aunt Cousens, Uncle D, Missy, Taff and the doctor at Halifax.

III

The last voyage

William was right about Thursday. On 10 April 1828 Acorn sailed from Bermuda for Halifax in company with HMS Tyne and HMS Hussar, which was flying the flag of Rear-Admiral Sir Charles Ogle. The Royal Gazette reported their departure the following week.

At the same time the gun-brig HMS Contest, under Lieutenant Edward Plaggenborg, was working the same route in the opposite direction. She had arrived at Halifax from Bermuda on 9 April and sailed again for Bermuda on the 13th. Within a few days of each other, the two ships were at sea on opposite legs of the same passage.

Then the weather turned. Halifax recorded snow and a “Heavy Blow” on 16 April, and the ships heading north appear to have been separated in a gale. Hussar eventually reached Halifax on 23 April after what was reported as a “most tempestuous Passage”, and Tyne came in two days later. By the end of April there was growing concern at Halifax that Acorn had not arrived.

Neither Acorn nor Contest was seen again. It’s tempting to say they were lost in the same storm, and they may well have been, but I can’t prove it. What the evidence does support is that both were lost during the same short spell of severe weather in mid-April 1828.

IV

“Convey this safe to England”

  • Written aboard H.M. Sloop Acorn, Bermuda, Sunday 6 April 1828
  • Carried by an invalided shipmate, in the transport very probably Southworth, sailed Ireland Island for Portsmouth 18 April 1828
  • Entry to the post red boxed PORTSMOUTH / SHIP LETTER
  • Other marks small circular MAY 23, probably Portsmouth
  • Charges 8 (8d inward ship letter) and 1/1 (8d + 5d inland, Portsmouth to Chichester)
  • Arrived Chichester backstamp, 23 May 1828; Ralph’s own “Rec’d … May 23”
  • Redirected to Wm Nunn Esq, Jesus College, Cambridge, “For Mrs W. Nunn”
  • Forwarded Chichester, 24 May 1828

While Acorn was heading north, William’s letter was still in Bermuda waiting for its ride home.

On 14 April the Bermuda post office advertised a sealed mail bag “per Transport Ship SOUTH-WARK, for ENGLAND, Direct”, closing on Thursday 17 April. The following week the Royal Gazette reported that the transport Southworth had sailed from Ireland Island on Friday 18 April for Portsmouth. Her passengers included Royal Navy personnel and “Some Invalids Royal Sappers and Miners, and some from 96th Regiment”. The spelling differs between the two notices. But the date, the destination, the type of ship and the invalids aboard all fit William’s description, and I’m satisfied this is very probably the transport that carried his letter.

What I can’t say is exactly how William’s shipmate kept his promise. He may have put the letter into the sealed bag, or carried it himself and handed it in on arrival. Either way, the letter shows where it entered the British post: a faint red boxed PORTSMOUTH / SHIP LETTER handstamp on the address panel. I have an 1819 letter from HMS Euryalus with the same marking in blue-green, so it was nice to find it in red. There is also a small circular MAY 23 mark, probably Portsmouth, though the town name is too faint to be certain.

The letter carries two manuscript charges. There’s an 8, which I read as the 8d inward ship letter charge, and the total of 1/1, which accounts exactly. Portsmouth to Chichester was reckoned at 18 miles, putting it in the 15–20 mile band at 5d. Eightpence for the ship letter plus fivepence inland comes to one shilling and a penny.

The letter was backstamped at Chichester on 23 May 1828. Ralph also noted its arrival himself on the top panel, “Rec’d at … May 23”. The place he wrote is too faint to read with any confidence, which is a pity, but the date matches the Chichester backstamp and his covering note exactly. It had been nearly seven weeks on the way.

April and May 1828

The ships on one side, the letter on the other.

The ships
The letter
Sun 6 Apr
The shipsAcorn at Bermuda. William writes to Mary.
The letterHanded to an invalided shipmate to carry home.
9 Apr
The shipsContest reaches Halifax from Bermuda.
Thu 10 Apr
The shipsAcorn sails for Halifax with Hussar and Tyne.
13 Apr
The shipsContest sails from Halifax for Bermuda.
14 Apr
The letterBermuda post office advertises a mail bag “per Transport Ship SOUTH-WARK, for ENGLAND”.
16 Apr
The shipsSnow and a “Heavy Blow” at Halifax.
17 Apr
The letterThe England mail bag closes.
Fri 18 Apr
The letterThe transport Southworth sails from Ireland Island for Portsmouth.
23 Apr
The shipsHussar reaches Halifax after a “most tempestuous Passage”.
25 Apr
The shipsTyne reaches Halifax.
By 29 Apr
The shipsGrowing concern at Halifax: Acorn has not arrived. Neither she nor Contest is seen again.
The letter crosses the Atlantic
23 May
The letterEnters the post at Portsmouth as a ship letter, charged 1/1. Reaches Chichester the same day, and Ralph opens it.
24 May
The letterForwarded from Chichester to Mary at Jesus College, Cambridge.
V

“Had many scruples whether I shou’d open this”

The letter was addressed to “Mrs Wm Nunn”. The rest of the original address has been scored out and can’t safely be read. From William’s questions about Penzance and Chilbolton, Mary was travelling, so it makes sense that he sent it to the family home, probably at Fishbourne, to be passed on.

It never got that far unopened. Ralph Clarke couldn’t wait, and he says so in the space William had left at the top of the first page:

Ralph Clarke's note of 23 May across the top of the first page, turned the right way up
Ralph’s note across the top of page one, turned the right way up

“May 23rd. My dearest Mary, Had many scruples whether I shou’d open this — thought you wou’d pardon my doing so. I was so anxious to hear about the dear Boy’s movements — if I have transgressed, pardon me.”

He then carries on around every free bit of paper, with little continuation marks showing where to read next. The Bishop was away from Chichester, so he couldn’t get a free frank to spare Mary the onward postage. There had been no offers yet for his horses. The two Miss Crofts had dined with them, and the Sunday school was going “admirably” with 36 scholars. And then:

“A few days ago I had a most satisfactory Letter from dear William Clarke — it will find its way to you in time.”

That will almost certainly be the letter William mentions in his postscript, sent to his father by the packet.

On the upper flap is a confidential note: “the matter between Mr. D and C.C.” had been broken off, “so never mention the subject to anyone”. I haven’t worked out who Mr D and C.C. were. Sorry, Ralph.

Nothing Ralph wrote on 23 May suggests he knew Acorn was missing. As far as he was concerned, his son was safely on his way to Halifax.

Ralph then struck through the original address and the 1/1 charge. He readdressed the letter to “Wm Nunn Esq, Jesus College, Cambridge”, added “For Mrs W. Nunn”, and wrote the Cambridge address again on the seal panel. The letter went back into the post at Chichester on 24 May 1828.

VI

“My dear lost son”

The entire folded, showing Ralph Clarke's note: My dear lost son William's letters 1827-1828, the last dated April 6th 1828, R.C.
The entire folded, with Ralph’s note on the front

We don’t know when the news reached the Clarkes, but at some point it did, and William didn’t come home.

Some time later Ralph wrote on the front of the letter:

My dear lost son William’s letters 1827–1828 the last dated April 6th 1828 R.C.

So Ralph kept William’s letters from 1827 and 1828, and this was the last of them. For it to carry his note, it must have come back to him from Cambridge at some point. It is the only one that survives.

As postal history, this is a very good Bermuda ship letter. But it’s William’s voice that stays with me. He was fifteen and a long way from home, looking forward to Halifax and the rest of the world, keeping stones in his chest for his sister and explaining to her how to carry a snug sail. Ralph kept all of William’s letters. This is the one still here.

The Ships · I

Lithograph of HMS Satellite, Acorn's sister ship, in a heavy gale on 28 February 1838 at latitude 29, longitude 64

H.M.S. Acorn

An 18-gun sloop launched at Chatham on 16 November 1826 and commanded in 1828 by Commander Edward Gordon. She was built to the same Admiralty plans as HMS Satellite.

In the absence of a picture of Acorn herself, the page shows two things. The first, here, is a lithograph of her sister Satellite in a heavy gale in 1838 at 29°N 64°W, not far south of Bermuda, drawn by a midshipman on board. It gives a good idea of how Acorn would have looked under sail. The second, below, is the actual construction drawing of Acorn’s keel, dated 14 March 1826 and signed by Robert Seppings, Surveyor of the Navy.

Rate18-gun sloop
LaunchedChatham, 16 November 1826
Officers, 1828Cdr Edward Gordon; Lt William Henry Gearey; Master William Clarke Purver
SailedBermuda for Halifax, 10 April 1828
FateLost with all hands, April 1828
Admiralty drawing dated 14 March 1826 showing the elevation and sections of the main and curved keels for a new 18-gun sloop ordered at Chatham, which became HMS Acorn
Navy Office drawing of Acorn’s keels, 14 March 1826, signed by Robert SeppingsRoyal Museums Greenwich, ZAZ4164. Satellite lithograph above: Royal Museums Greenwich, PAD6136.

The Ships · II

Admiralty sheer and profile drawing for the 12-gun gun-brigs, listing Contest among the ships built to the design

H.M.S. Contest

A 12-gun gun-brig in service from 1812, commanded in 1828 by Lieutenant Edward Plaggenborg. She reached Halifax from Bermuda on 9 April 1828 and sailed on the return passage on the 13th. She never arrived.

The Admiralty plan shown lists Contest among the brigs built to the design and is signed by the Surveyors of the Navy, William Rule and Henry Peake. Royal Museums Greenwich, ZAZ4875.

Rate12-gun gun-brig
In servicefrom 1812
Commander, 1828Lt Edward Plaggenborg
SailedHalifax for Bermuda, 13 April 1828
FateLost, April 1828

Still to find out

If you can help with any of these, I’d be very pleased to hear from you.

Read the full transcription

Two hands: William Clarke, 6 April 1828 Ralph Clarke, 23 May 1828 and later

William · page one

H.M. Sloop Acorn Bermuda Sunday April 6th 1828 —

My dearest Mary —

On Thursday for certain we sail for Halifax; one of our Mates is obliged to invalid, & has promised to convey this safe to England, to which place he returns in a Transport lately arrived here with Provisions — I can scarcely believe that in a few days I shall be in a Country so different to this, where the very breath of one freezes — During the time we have lain here the Thermometer has never been lower than 56 or 55 and generally from 65 to 75 sometimes warmer —

I long to be on the move and look forward with pleasure to visit other Parts of the world — Taff has promised to give me a Letter of Introduction to some relations of the doctor at Halifax which I hope will prove useful — When I return which I expect will be in about two Years shou’d you live near the water we will have some pleasant sails & cruises —

Ralph · across the top of page one

May 23rd. My dearest Mary,

Had many scruples whether I shou’d open this — thought you wou’d pardon my doing so. I was so anxious to hear about the dear Boy’s movements — if I have transgressed, pardon me.

Ralph · margin and foot of page one

Your affe. Father, Ralph Clarke. A Frank I cannot now obtain — the Bishop not being at Chichester — no offer for my horses yet — The two Miss Crofts dined with us yesterday.

William · page two

The Shoals are certainly dangerous but the wind is not if proper care is taken to carry a snug Sail & not carry on too much — You will be able to make out what I mean no doubt — What a Pity it wou’d be shou’d Douglas be obliged to leave the Service —

How long do you intend staying at Penzance and what are your movements after having visited Chilbolton — How a’ you be then when this reaches you give my Love to Aunt Cousens & my remembrance to Uncle D — I saw in the Paper that Lady Curtis was again confined what a Breeder!! when you see them remember me to her & to the rest of the Family but give my Love and a Kiss to Missy — Tell me all about them in your next.

Lady C is such a nice woman that I quite love her so affable & agreeable — William C. is I suppose still at Miss — how fond Ralph was of them all — John indeed must have felt much disappointed and I cannot help admiring him for not having said a word about it himself

William · page three

but merely that he was appointed to the Infantry — We must be thankful for having obtained a cadetship at all — I am confident he will make a brave & good Soldier & will distinguish himself — He would do well in any thing from a Tinker to a King —

Our dear Father is all kindness to me and I may say that I was fitted out in every thing proper for a Gent. Does Wm’s Health still continue to be good, remember me to him with my best wishes —

Most curious stone is blown from the rocks, it is congealed as water. I have preserved some nice pieces and will send them to you but the carriage would be more than their value. They will be safe in my Chest till I come home —

This is the worst Station for Shells that there is; the best I can get you are welcome to —

I have now spun you a long Yarn and will conclude — hoping my dear Girl that you will enjoy Health and every possible Blessing.

And believe me Your affectionate Brother Wm Clarke

William · postscript on the right-hand flap

I wrote to Father a few days ago per Packet. When you write, give my love to him.

William · original address (struck through)

Mrs Wm Nunn [remainder scored out and unreadable]

Ralph · left-hand flap

Mr. & Mrs. Croft & Fanny set off for St Omer a week ago — I have heard from good old Hinton, she particularly desires her kindest wishes to you — also Miss Bull and a host of people at Clanville — A few days ago I had a most satisfactory Letter from dear William Clarke — it will find its way to you in time — Our Sunday School goes on admirably — we have 36 Scholars at it — Adieu, love from all here to you & Will Nunn. Your affe. Father, Ralph Clarke.

Ralph · upper flap

The matter between Mr. D and C.C. that I alluded to as being settled, has exactly been abruptly broken off by Mr. D — so never mention the subject to anyone. R.C.

Ralph · top panel

Rec’d at … May 23 [place unreadable]

Ralph · redirection

Wm Nunn Esq Jesus College Cambridge

For Mrs W. Nunn.

Repeated on the seal panel: William Nunn Esq. Jesus College Cambridge.

Ralph · later, on the front

My dear lost son William’s letters 1827–1828 the last dated April 6th 1828 R.C.

See also

My research continues, and I’ll update this page as I learn more.