Postal History · Royal Navy · Atlantic Fleet

H.M.S. Dominion

Bermuda · September 1906 – January 1907

Five postcards from a damaged battleship’s four months in the floating dock.

◆

I have five postcards for the Dominion, and between them they cover her whole stay at Bermuda. She was a brand-new battleship, named in honour of Canada. In August 1906 she ran onto a shoal in Chaleur Bay during a goodwill tour of Canada, and Bermuda’s new floating dock was the place to patch her up. Three of the cards were written by men on board, one was sent to a man on board, and one was never used. With the Royal Gazette alongside, I’ve been able to name most of the people involved. Two of them turned out to be officers I’d already found on a cricket scorecard.

I

After the hurricane

Tinted picture postcard captioned Hamilton, Bermuda. H M. S. Psyche in Dock: a cruiser with two funnels sitting high and dry inside the old floating dock, the dock's curved iron side on the left and a steel gantry overhead, workmen standing on the dock floor. Written in ink up the right-hand edge: H.M.S. Dominion, Ireland Island, Bermuda, 12/9/06, from one who is melting away
“H.M.S. Psyche in Dock”, headed “H.M.S. ‘Dominion’ – Ireland Island – Bermuda – 12/9/06”
Message side of a Souvenir Post-Card published by J. H. Bradley & Co., Qualified Chemists, Hamilton, Bermuda, No. 50, franked with a 1d Dock stamp tied by an Ireland Island datestamp. Message on the left: This is an extra mail, & am writing properly on the 14th, its too hot here for much energy. We take up our quarters in the Terror to-morrow, the Dom being docked on Friday next, we had 2 extra days at sea in an awful hurricane. Yrs. Anderson. Addressed to P. B. Stoner Esq., 39 Hampton Place, Brighton, Sussex, England
Anderson to P. B. Stoner, Brighton
  • From “Anderson”, almost certainly Assistant Clerk Frederick J. S. Anderson
  • To P. B. Stoner Esq., 39 Hampton Place, Brighton
  • Card J. H. Bradley & Co., Hamilton, No. 50
  • Postage 1d Dock, the postcard rate to Britain
  • Datestamp Ireland Island, 13 September 1906
Royal Gazette, Naval Notes: Up to the time of going to press it was not known with certainty when H.M.S. Dominion might be expected to arrive. The dock is being prepared for her reception and additional shipwrights have been engaged for the work on her. The following is a list of the Dominion's officers: Captain Charles E Kingsmill, Commander Hon Edward S H Boyle, Lieutenants including (N) Basil S Noake and Bernard K Boase, Lieutenants R.N.R. Peter O Griffiths and Edward D Drury, Engineer Lieutenant Philip D Church, Lieutenant R.M.A. Freeman C N Bishop, Lieutenant R.M. John E L Wilton, Midshipmen including William H Sandford, Arthur R Banks, Cecil S Sandford, Paul F P Berryman, Basil J Pailthorpe and John B Spurgin, Clerk James R Hemsted, Assistant Clerk Frederick J S Anderson
Royal Gazette, 25 August 1906: the dock is made ready, and the Dominion’s officers
Royal Gazette, Arrival of H.M.S. Dominion: The first class battleship Dominion arrived at Murray's Anchorage from Canada yesterday afternoon after a somewhat rough passage, the vessel having encountered the full force of the recent gale. The Dominion was sighted on Saturday afternoon some few miles off the island, and the weather being unpropitious she steamed further out to sea. The article goes on to describe her as the largest warship that has visited Bermudian waters, gives her dimensions, armament and crew of 777 officers and men, the Canadian presentation of a silver shield, cup and cigar boxes, and her striking a reef in the Baie des Chaleurs, and notes that Captain Kingsmill is a native of Guelph, Ontario
Royal Gazette, 11 September 1906: “the full force of the recent gale”
Royal Gazette, Naval Notes: H.M.S. Dominion was safely docked in the new Dock at H. M. Dockyard at noon on Tuesday, 18th inst. The weather during the whole of the previous week was very boisterous and it was not possible to commence docking till Monday morning at 7 a.m. The big ship was soon inside the dock, but it was a very anxious time during the raising of the dock and ship, for nearly thirty hours the work was carried on. We understand H.M.S. Dominion is the heaviest ship that has ever been lifted in a dock of this kind, in addition to her weight there was two or three thousand tons of water in her hold. The damage to the ship is found to be very extensive. It is understood she will only be temporarily repaired here and then proceed to England
Royal Gazette, 22 September 1906: up in the dock

The first card was written two days after she arrived. It’s a J. H. Bradley & Co. souvenir card, No. 50, and the picture is H.M.S. Psyche in the old floating dock. Across the front the writer added: “H.M.S. ‘Dominion’ – Ireland Island – Bermuda – 12/9/06, from one who is melting away.” On the back, to P. B. Stoner Esq. in Brighton:

“This is an extra mail, & am writing properly on the 14th – its too hot here for much energy. We take up our quarters in the ‘Terror’ to-morrow, the ‘Dom’ being docked on Friday next – we had 2 extra days at sea in an awful hurricane.”

Anderson, 12 September 1906

It’s signed Anderson. The Dominion’s officers’ list in the Gazette has an Assistant Clerk, Frederick J. S. Anderson, and I’m fairly sure that’s him.

The Gazette backs up every line. She was sighted off the island on Saturday 8 September, but “the weather being unpropitious she steamed further out to sea”. She came into Murray’s Anchorage on the Monday afternoon “after a somewhat rough passage”. The Terror was the Dockyard’s depot ship, and while their ship was out of the water the men lived on board her.

He was a little optimistic about Friday. The weather stayed “very boisterous”, and docking didn’t start until 7 a.m. on Monday 17 September. She was safely up at noon the next day, after nearly thirty hours. The Gazette understood she was “the heaviest ship that has ever been lifted in a dock of this kind”, with two or three thousand tons of water still in her hold.

The card is franked with a 1d Dock, the postcard rate to Britain, and has an Ireland Island datestamp of 13 September.

II

A card from Ottawa

Black and white picture postcard captioned in red Parliament Hill, Ottawa, Canada: the Gothic Parliament buildings and the round Library of Parliament on top of a wooded bluff, seen across the Ottawa River, with boats and sheds along the shore below
“Parliament Hill, Ottawa, Canada”
Message side of a Private Post Card published by Bryson, Graham & Co., Ottawa, franked with two Canada 1 cent King Edward VII stamps with machine cancels and an Ottawa datestamp, September 1906, 9 PM. Message: Ottawa. Some of the photos come from Quebec and they are simply splendid. I will send them to you as soon as the others arrive. C.B. Addressed to C. S. Sandford Esq., H.M.S. Dominion, Atlantic Fleet, Bermuda. An Ireland Island receiving datestamp is struck over the dividing line
C.B. to C. S. Sandford, H.M.S. Dominion
  • From “C.B.”, Ottawa
  • To C. S. Sandford Esq., H.M.S. Dominion, Atlantic Fleet, Bermuda
  • Card Bryson, Graham & Co., Ottawa
  • Postage 2 × 1c, the foreign postcard rate
  • Datestamp Ottawa, 13 September 1906, 9 PM, with machine cancels
  • Receiver Ireland Island, [2]3 September 1906; the month has gone, but only September fits
Royal Gazette, Cricket, H.M.S. Dominion vs. Hamilton C.C.: The return cricket match between H.M.S. Dominion C.C. and the Hamilton C.C. attracted a large number of spectators to the Richmond Cricket Ground on Thursday afternoon when the visitors were at home to the local eleven. The band of the Dominion was in attendance and played a capital selection of music. The Hamilton C.C. declared their innings closed after 5 wickets had fallen for 146, R. Conyers being responsible for 71. The seamen knocked up 74 in the first innings and 61 for eight wickets in the second innings when a shower of rain interrupted further cricket, and the ladies and friends of the Club were entertained by the Dominion people with refreshments. The programme of music was supplied by the band under Bandmaster R. Castleman
Royal Gazette, 29 September 1906: the Dominion at the Richmond ground
Royal Gazette scorecard, Dominion C.C. first innings: Mr Bishop, Trimmer, Berryman, Nooke, W H Sandford, S C Sandford, Boyce, Church, Selthorpe, Banks and Drury, total 74. Second innings including Sandford (I) and Sandford (II), total 61. Hamilton C.C.: R Conyers caught Sandford (II) bowled Boyce 71, H Butterfield 23, H J Tucker caught Sandford (II), total 146. The umpire for the Dominion team was Mr. Wilton
The scorecard: two Sandfords in the Dominion’s eleven

The day after Anderson’s card, someone signing “C.B.” posted this card of Parliament Hill from Ottawa, to “C. S. Sandford Esq., H.M.S. Dominion, Atlantic Fleet, Bermuda”:

“Some of the photos come from Quebec and they are simply splendid. I will send them to you as soon as the others arrive.”

C.B., Ottawa, 13 September 1906

Dominion had been at Quebec in late August, with Captain Kingsmill hosting the Governor General on board. The people of Canada presented the ship with a silver shield, a cup and six silver cigar boxes made from Canadian silver. Those must be the photos.

The handwriting made the name hard work. The Gazette solved it twice. On 29 September it printed the scorecard of a cricket match at the Richmond ground between H.M.S. Dominion C.C. and Hamilton C.C., and two Sandfords played for the ship. The officers’ list a month earlier names them both: Midshipmen William H. Sandford and Cecil S. Sandford. The card reached Ireland Island on 23 September, four days before Cecil played. The ship’s band played through the match. The ship lost, and when rain stopped play the Dominion people gave the ladies tea.

I think Cecil Stanley Sandford went on to serve as a lieutenant-commander in H.M.S. Invincible in the First World War, but I haven’t proved it’s the same man yet.

The card is franked with two 1 cent stamps, the foreign postcard rate, and machine cancelled at Ottawa on 13 September 1906, 9 PM. The Ireland Island receiver on the message side has lost its month, but only September makes sense.

III

In the floating dock

Black and white picture postcard captioned New Floating Dock, Dockyard, Bermuda. H.M.S. Dominion in dock: the battleship seen bow-on, high and dry inside the floating dock, her ram bow towering over the dock floor, with hundreds of sailors lining her forecastle, the dock's steel walkways and the shores below, and a man in a pith helmet standing on the gangway in the foreground
“New Floating Dock, Dockyard, Bermuda. H.M.S. Dominion in dock.”
  • Card J. H. Bradley & Co., Hamilton, No. 130
  • Condition Unused
Royal Gazette, Naval Funeral: On Sunday last at the Naval Cemetery, Ireland Island took place the funeral of Leading Stoker Montague Ayling of H.M.S. Dominion who died of enteric fever. The funeral was at 4.30 p.m. and was attended by the whole ship's company and the full band
Royal Gazette, 30 October 1906: Leading Stoker Montague Ayling

This is the card everyone at the Dockyard must have wanted: J. H. Bradley & Co. No. 130, “New Floating Dock, Dockyard, Bermuda. H.M.S. Dominion in dock.” Mine is unused. The photograph shows her bow towering over the dock walls, with half the ship’s company posing along the rails.

Repairs took four months. In November the Gazette reported all available men working from 7 a.m. to 9 p.m., with half an hour for dinner and the same for tea. In the House of Commons it was said her bottom was damaged along about 280 feet. She would only be patched at Bermuda, and the real work would be done at Chatham.

Not everyone went home. On Sunday 28 October Leading Stoker Montague Ayling, who had died of enteric fever, was buried in the Naval Cemetery at Ireland Island, with the whole ship’s company and the full band. The proceeds of the ship’s theatrical troupe’s concert the following week went to his family.

IV

“Still alive”

Tinted picture postcard captioned in red Somerset Bridge, Bermuda: the long low bridge on stone piers running across the water towards houses with red roofs, four men in hats standing by a lamp post in the foreground
“Somerset Bridge, Bermuda”
Message side of a Bermuda POST CARD with the royal arms, published by Charles J. Mitchell Co., Limited, No. 766, endorsed top left Dominion, Bermuda, West Indies, franked with a 1d Dock stamp tied by a Hamilton datestamp 7 JA 1907, code A. Message: Dear E. just a line to let you know I am still alive, I would have wrote a letter only the mail is leaving four days earlier. Why haven't you written, if you are going to write do so soon or else I shall not get it for a long time for we are leaving here end of the month. Addressed to Miss Elsie Paine, 11 Cornhill, Bridgwater, Somerset, England
To Miss Elsie Paine, Bridgwater
  • From “Luno” (best guess at the signature)
  • To Miss Elsie Paine, 11 Cornhill, Bridgwater, Somerset
  • Card Charles J. Mitchell Co., Limited, No. 766
  • Postage 1d Dock
  • Datestamp Hamilton, Ludington type H7, 7 JA 1907, code A (morning collection)

“Dear E. just a line to let you know I am still alive, I would have wrote a letter only the mail is leaving four days earlier … for we are leaving here end of the month.”

“Dominion”, Bermuda, January 1907

This is a Charles J. Mitchell Co. card, No. 766, of Somerset Bridge. It’s endorsed “Dominion, Bermuda, West Indies” and addressed to Miss Elsie Paine, 11 Cornhill, Bridgwater. It’s franked with a 1d Dock and datestamped at Hamilton on 7 January 1907, collection A, the morning collection.

My best guess at the signature is Luno. She did sail at the end of the month, so he was right.

V

Out of dock

Black and white picture postcard captioned H.M.S. Dominion in New Dry Dock, Bermuda, 1906: the same bow-on photograph of the battleship in the floating dock, with the message written in the white margin on the right: 15.1.06. Dear N. Am sorry I have neglected you so long, many thanks for your p.p.cs. Dominion came out of dock on Friday last. Due to sail on 21st. Brilliant due tomorrow for a refit. American steamer Ponce goes in dock tomorrow with a broken shaft. Was towed in here by a German. Best wishes for a pleasant time in Sunny South. Happy and prosperous New Year, signed with initials
“H.M.S. ‘Dominion’ in New Dry Dock, Bermuda, 1906”, with the message
The address on the back of the card, in ink: Mr J. O. Newnham, 2nd Writer, H.M.S. Indefatigable, West Indies. The stamp has been removed, leaving only the lower part of a datestamp
The address: J. O. Newnham, 2nd Writer, H.M.S. Indefatigable
  • From Signed with initials I can’t read for certain
  • To Mr J. O. Newnham, 2nd Writer, H.M.S. Indefatigable, West Indies
  • Card Printed in New York
  • Postage Stamp missing
  • Datestamp Only “BER” of Bermuda remains
  • Date Written “15.1.06”; actually 15 January 1907
Royal Gazette, H.M.S. Dominion: After several months in dock at Ireland Island, temporary repairs have been effected to the bottom of H.M.S. Dominion. On Friday the floating dock was submerged and the vessel was berthed alongside the Dockyard. During this week the Dominion will coal and afterwards swing for adjustment of compasses. According to present arrangements the vessel will sail for Chatham, England, on Monday next
Royal Gazette, 15 January 1907: out of dock on Friday
Royal Gazette, The S.S. Ponce: The news that the American steamer Ponce is safe is most welcome, as underwriters were threatened with a loss on hull and cargo of about 100,000 pounds. She was much overdue on the voyage from Puerto Rico for New York and was towed into Bermuda by the German steamer Elisabeth Rickmers. London Times, Jan 18th
Royal Gazette, 12 February 1907: the German was the Elisabeth Rickmers

This is my favourite of the five. The card was printed in New York and the stamp has gone; all that’s left of the datestamp is “BER”. It’s addressed to J. O. Newnham, 2nd Writer, H.M.S. Indefatigable, West Indies. The writer dated it “15.1.06”, but he’d forgotten it was a new year:

“‘Dominion’ came out of dock on Friday last. Due to sail on 21st. ‘Brilliant’ due tomorrow for a refit. American steamer ‘Ponce’ goes in dock tomorrow with a broken shaft. Was towed in here by a German. Best wishes for a pleasant time in Sunny South.”

To J. O. Newnham, 15 January 1907

The Gazette of 15 January 1907 confirms it: on Friday the dock was submerged and the ship berthed alongside, and she was to sail on “Monday next”, the 21st. The Ponce had left Puerto Rico on Christmas Day and been posted overdue. The US revenue cutters were out searching for her until news came that she was safe at Bermuda. The Gazette later named the German: the steamer Elisabeth Rickmers, which had towed her in.

The Indefatigable had been at Bermuda with the Dominion until 26 October, when she sailed for Barbados, and I suspect that’s where the two men met. Newnham was a Writer, the Navy’s name for a clerk, and the card is signed with initials I can’t read for certain. I like that it’s two sailors passing on the Dockyard news.

VI

Home, and the court martial

Royal Gazette: Feb. 8th. The Dominion arrived at the Nore from Bermuda, and during the afternoon carried out a two hours' steam trial in the North Sea. On Saturday she proceeded into Sheerness Harbour and unshipped her war department stores. She proceeded to Chatham on Tuesday and was docked next day for repairs. A correspondent to The Daily Mail says great credit is due to the dockyard staff at Bermuda for the efficient manner in which the temporary repairs to H.M.S. Dominion were carried out, in spite of the fact that the depletion last summer of the Dockyard of tools and material necessary to such work rendered it a much greater task than it would have been before their removal. When the ship was taken into dock her estimated weight was 22,000 tons, as she had at least 2,000 tons of water in her injured compartments
Royal Gazette, 5 March 1907: safe at the Nore, and credit to the Bermuda Dockyard
Royal Gazette, The Grounding of H.M.S. Dominion, Court Martial, Captain and Navigating Officer Severely Reprimanded: London, March 5. A naval courtmartial sitting at Chatham has found Capt. Chas. E. Kingsmill and Lieut Basil S. Noake guilty by default of suffering the battleship Dominion to be stranded in the St. Lawrence River August 18 of last year. The two officers were sentenced to be severely reprimanded
Royal Gazette, 9 March 1907: “severely reprimanded”

She sailed on 22 January, under orders for England, with timber in her bottom and “still leaking”. She reached the Nore on 8 February. A Daily Mail correspondent gave great credit to the Bermuda Dockyard staff, and said that when she was docked she weighed an estimated 22,000 tons, with at least 2,000 tons of water in her damaged compartments.

Not everyone was so sure. In February the Gazette passed on a London Daily Chronicle report that her back was broken and her engines out of alignment, and that the best that could be done was to patch her up for harbour service. She was back in service with the Channel Fleet by the summer.

In March a court martial at Chatham found Captain Charles Kingsmill and his navigating officer, Lieutenant Basil Noake, guilty of letting her be stranded, and both were severely reprimanded. In the dark they had taken a bush fire on shore for the Souris Point light. Lieutenant Noake turns up in the Dominion’s eleven on that cricket scorecard. At the hearing Kingsmill read out an Admiralty letter commending the way the repairs were carried out at Bermuda.

Four months at Bermuda

The ship on one side, the postcards on the other.

The ship
The postcards
16 Aug 1906
The shipGrounds off Souris Point, Chaleur Bay.
22 Aug
The shipThe Canadian presentation at Quebec.
8–10 Sep
The shipSighted off Bermuda in the hurricane; into Murray’s Anchorage on the 10th.
12–13 Sep
The postcardsAnderson writes to Brighton (card 1). C.B. posts the Ottawa card to Sandford (card 2).
17–18 Sep
The shipLifted in the floating dock.
23 Sep
The postcardsThe Ottawa card reaches Ireland Island.
27 Sep
The shipCricket against Hamilton C.C. at the Richmond ground.
28 Oct
The shipFuneral of Leading Stoker Montague Ayling.
7 Jan 1907
The postcards“Still alive”, to Elsie Paine (card 4).
11 Jan
The shipOut of the floating dock.
15 Jan
The postcardsThe card to Newnham in the Indefatigable (card 5).
22 Jan
The shipSails for England, still leaking.
8 Feb
The shipReaches the Nore.
Mar 1907
The shipCourt martial at Chatham.

The Ship

Black and white photograph of the battleship HMS Dominion at anchor, seen from the starboard side: a long dark hull with two tall funnels close together amidships, two masts with fighting tops, twin 12-inch gun turrets fore and aft and smaller turrets at the corners of the superstructure

H.M.S. Dominion

H.M.S. Dominion was a King Edward VII-class battleship, built by Vickers at Barrow, launched on 25 August 1903 and commissioned at Portsmouth in August 1905. Captain Charles Kingsmill, born in Guelph, Ontario, took command in March 1906. After his reprimand he retired in 1908 and went home to found the Royal Canadian Navy. Dominion was repaired at Chatham in 1907, served with the 3rd Battle Squadron in the First World War, and was sold for scrap in May 1921.

BuiltVickers, Barrow; launched 25 August 1903
TypeKing Edward VII-class pre-dreadnought battleship
Guns4 × 12-in, 4 × 9.2-in, 10 × 6-in; 16,350 tons
CaptainC. E. Kingsmill, 1906–07
FateSold for scrap, May 1921

Dominion, Symonds & Co., 1909. Imperial War Museum (Q 21170), via Wikimedia Commons.

Still to find out

If you can help with any of these, I’d be very pleased to hear from you.

References

Five ordinary cards, and between them a hurricane, a cricket match, a funeral and a battleship sent home with a wooden bottom. I like that the men who wrote them can still be found on the Gazette’s pages.